YES, a rejection letter!
I am sure this sounds peculiar, but to finally get a response after sending out several dozen query letters is a success in my eyes. It breaks the perpetual waiting cycle and lets you know someone actually looked at your submission.
This recent rejection letter came in reference to my newest completed novel and it was a pretty quick response as it came after only two weeks. I think this may be a record because in the world of fiction writing it seems a bit rare to hear anything back from an agency in under a month…if at all.
Many agencies have hundreds, if not thousands of requests to review and they just don’t have time or staff to answer them all. In this case, it seems this project did not resonate with the agent. She stated the following:
“It may not seem this way, but saying no is tough for me. I’m sure hearing it is tough for you, but it’s really important for me to fall in love with a project and that just did not happen in this case. Please know that I really appreciate your patience during this process and I truly wish you the best of luck in finding the right agent! I’ll be rooting for you!”
There is not a lot of detail here, but it was an easy letdown and at least I have a firm answer, “No Thank you” This is one of the first queries I’ve sent out on this current project, so one rejection is not a trend, but the reality is that others may say no, and the project may not get picked up.
If it does get rejected by all other agents, one has to remember there is as much to be learned in rejection as there is in success…it just depends on your frame of mind.
If you can’t tell by my previous statement, I ‘m an optimist. That’s not to say I don’t have my moments of self-loathing where the situation gets the best of me, but all in all, I see rejection as an opportunity to learn and ask a few questions and face it, it’s better to be the glass is half full person anyway!
Several questions I ask myself as I continue to market my project:
- Was this agent the right one to query in the first place? i.e. does my project align with what they have represented in the past?
I knew this current agent was a long shot, but at least she reviewed it and replied.
- Is the project/manuscript really ready?
As a writer, I don’t know if you are ever “really” done editing, but in this case, I felt well prepared… (We all know that even after its printed and sent out we still find errors, and face it, we are our own worst critics, it will NEVER be perfect)
- Has the work been reviewed by someone else?
When writing, we spend a lot of time looking at the same piece of work and simple errors can get overlooked. So, unless we have someone else critiquing our work, and not your mom, sister, or brother, we run the risk of missing simple errors… and sometimes big ones. So, find an editor, they can make all the difference in the success of your writing project.
A great place to find an editor or help on your project is over at reedsy.com
- Do I have honest, brutal feedback?
In my case, I have worked with a couple of successful editors that have major projects and titles under their belts. They have helped me put the time in on this project…and at times, their feedback was brutal but professional, and it was exactly what was needed.
In the end, I see this response as another step in the process and I will keep plugging away in hopes that I sell this project…and if I don’t, I will learn a lot along the way.
All in all, there is a lot to be learned from a few rejections.